Vote for the Scottish Album of the Decade

Feature by Rab Shatner.
Published 27 October 2009

With the noughties fast coming to a close, it's time to get the definitive answer on a question which has fuelled a few pub debates around these parts in recent months: What was the Scottish album of the decade?*

Rather than produce a shortlist from our arse, we want to compile your opinions for a future issue of The Skinny. To cast a vote please place your nomination in the subject heading of an e-mail and send it in to dave@theskinny.co.uk by no later than 5pm on Friday 6th November.

Alternatively you can tell us who you think should take the honours in the comments section below.

 

*Released on or after 1 January 2000.

Comments (46)

Add a comment »
  • Idlewild - The Remote Part

    Posted by Chris Lindsay | Tuesday October 2009 @ 13:19

    Report to moderator
  • Aereogramme - Sleep and Release. Stunning, stunning piece of work by a much missed band. One of the greatest opening riffs to an album ever, and no let up in its feral power right to the final hum of feedback.

    Posted by Evil Stu | Tuesday October 2009 @ 13:42

    Report to moderator
  • Mogwai - Young Team

    Posted by Lukus Gothenburgas Maximus | Tuesday October 2009 @ 14:55

    Report to moderator
  • McCluskey brothers - housewives choice

    Posted by George Heggarty | Tuesday October 2009 @ 16:19

    Report to moderator
  • biffy clyro - puzzle top notch

    Posted by james arnott | Tuesday October 2009 @ 16:26

    Report to moderator
  • XTRMNTR - Primal Scream

    Posted by Luce | Tuesday October 2009 @ 16:54

    Report to moderator
  • either: frightened rabbit - Midnight Organ Fight or
    meursault - pissing on bonfires/kissing with tongues - though that shouldn't count cos he's a mate...

    Posted by scott last battle | Tuesday October 2009 @ 19:22

    Report to moderator
  • The Jesus and Mary Chain - Psychocandy

    Posted by Dee | Tuesday October 2009 @ 22:20

    Report to moderator
  • it seems some people are mistaking a decade for a century...

    anyhow, it has to be Primal Sceam - XTRMNTR. hard to believe that the decade peaked in January 2000 but it's the troof!!

    Posted by Ian Crichton | Wednesday October 2009 @ 11:25

    Report to moderator
  • it has to be arab strap's "the red thread"

    has to be.

    Posted by Jamie Scott | Wednesday October 2009 @ 11:56

    Report to moderator
  • I think we are The Physics had a great debut album last year.
    At least worth a listen since they're smallish band

    Posted by Malcolm Middleton | Wednesday October 2009 @ 13:47

    Report to moderator
  • I have no doubt.
    Come On Die Young by Mogwai

    Posted by PD Lame | Thursday October 2009 @ 00:33

    Report to moderator
  • Midnight Organ fight - Frightened rabbit fo sho!

    Posted by mark | Thursday October 2009 @ 14:15

    Report to moderator
  • 100 Broken Windows - Idlewild

    Also think Vertigo of Bliss is worth a shout by Biffy. Lots of quality stuff on there.

    Posted by Steven | Thursday October 2009 @ 17:14

    Report to moderator
  • for me, arab strap - monday at the hug and pint.

    Posted by laura | Thursday October 2009 @ 20:09

    Report to moderator
  • Campfire Headphase, Boards of Canada

    Posted by Alex | Friday October 2009 @ 18:38

    Report to moderator
  • King Creosote - KC Rules OK

    Posted by flump | Saturday October 2009 @ 20:43

    Report to moderator
  • Depressing lack of ladies in the bands suggested so far! I'd go with Camera Obscura - Let's Get Out of This Country.

    Posted by Gail Tolley | Sunday November 2009 @ 12:43

    Report to moderator
  • Shoosh - Orpheum Circuit

    Posted by I Hate Commercialism | Monday November 2009 @ 15:45

    Report to moderator
  • king creosote - kc rules ok

    Posted by mark | Monday November 2009 @ 15:47

    Report to moderator
  • Manda Rin - My DNA

    Posted by Ste McCabe | Monday November 2009 @ 19:20

    Report to moderator
  • Miss The Occupier - Recovery Position.

    Posted by Lukas Waclawski | Monday November 2009 @ 19:22

    Report to moderator
  • Arab Strap - Monday at the Hug and Pint

    Posted by Bjorn | Tuesday November 2009 @ 11:57

    Report to moderator
  • Arab Strap - Monday At The Hug And Pint

    Posted by MUSIC ISN'T A COMPETITION! | Tuesday November 2009 @ 12:43

    Report to moderator
  • The Delgados - Hate

    Posted by badgercorn | Tuesday November 2009 @ 19:39

    Report to moderator
  • The Electroluvs - Bubblewrapped

    Posted by Paul T D | Tuesday November 2009 @ 21:20

    Report to moderator
  • Much as I love both Mogwai and Arab Strap, I feel their best work was done in the 1990s, and would fight shy of nominating their lesser albums.
    How about Life Without Building's Any Other City (2001)?
    http://www.myspace.com/lifewithoutbuildingsuk

    "My lips are sealed..."

    Posted by Gareth K Vile | Wednesday November 2009 @ 10:40

    Report to moderator
  • Annies Well - Luxury Car

    Posted by Bronson | Wednesday November 2009 @ 11:18

    Report to moderator
  • Mouse Eat Mouse - Mair Licht

    Flabbergasting!

    Posted by Michael Stich | Wednesday November 2009 @ 11:21

    Report to moderator
  • The 2002 Panini Scottish Premier League album was a classic.

    Posted by Battles | Wednesday November 2009 @ 12:36

    Report to moderator
  • Of course- Life Without Buildings! Gareth is totally right- it seems like that came out in a different universe though, it was so long ago...

    Posted by Ewen | Wednesday November 2009 @ 12:42

    Report to moderator
  • Ganger - Hammock Style, or Primal Scream - XTRMNTR

    Posted by Chris | Wednesday November 2009 @ 18:06

    Report to moderator
  • KC's 'Rocket DIY' pisses all over 'KC Rules Ok'

    Posted by Bjorn | Thursday November 2009 @ 16:03

    Report to moderator
  • Midnight Organ Fight - Frightened Rabbit.

    Posted by Jo | Thursday November 2009 @ 17:31

    Report to moderator
  • No-one has said The Twilight Sad's Fourteen Autumns And Fifteen Winters yet.
    Why has no-one said The Twilight Sad's Fourteen Autumns And Fifteen Winters yet?
    The Twilight Sad's Fourteen Autumns And Fifteen Winters.

    Posted by Ryan | Thursday November 2009 @ 19:10

    Report to moderator
  • A Band Called Quinn - Sun Moon Stars.

    Posted by David | Friday November 2009 @ 14:02

    Report to moderator
  • Why are the majority of albums mentioned in here released in the last two years? There are 10 years of Scottish Music to pick from!

    Posted by Frankie Miller | Friday November 2009 @ 14:16

    Report to moderator
  • Boards of Canada - Geogaddi

    Posted by Colm | Saturday November 2009 @ 11:10

    Report to moderator
  • Uncle John and Whitelock - There is nothing else

    Posted by Michael | Wednesday November 2009 @ 00:16

    Report to moderator
  • For my money all of the following would be contenders: Geogaddi by Boards of Canada, the debut from Uncle John, Twilight Sad's 14 Autumns, 15 Winters and two massively notable ommisions - Mend by Derosa and No Ceremony by Y'all is Fantasy Island! Oh and the Remember, Remember album was pretty good!

    Posted by Gee | Thursday November 2009 @ 15:13

    Report to moderator
  • I have to go for 1) Primal Scream - XTRMNTR 2) Mogwai - Mr Beast and 3)The Delgados - Hate.

    BTW...As much as I love the first 2 Mogwai albums, they are records from the 90's.

    Posted by Dave Arse | Friday November 2009 @ 08:00

    Report to moderator
  • you're a bit late to the party yourself, Dave. The votes have long since been counted!

    Posted by Bobby Shit | Friday November 2009 @ 10:35

    Report to moderator
  • Frightened Rabbit - The Midnight Organ Fight.

    Posted by Romeo's Girl | Friday November 2009 @ 12:30

    Report to moderator
  • Aereogramme - Sleep and Release!

    Posted by Timmy C | Friday November 2009 @ 14:12

    Report to moderator
  • Camera Obscura - Let's Get Out of this Country

    Posted by Moira | Friday November 2009 @ 14:13

    Report to moderator
  • I wish they would Moira, I wish they would...

    Posted by zeb | Saturday November 2009 @ 14:03

    Report to moderator
Leave a comment on this article